German Chocolate Cake
Kielbasa Dip
Fries
German Burger
Reuben Sandwich
Pierogi Plate
Corned Beef
Jägerschnitzel
Bloody Mary
Rueben Balls
Dumpling
Reuben Balls
Schnitzel Sandwich
Käsespätzle
German Nachos and Dumplings
Shepherd Pie
Haus Burger with Pommes Frites
Schnitzel Holstein
Lemonade
Kielbasa Balls
If you’re curious about what makes Marys Stein Haus Menu such a local favorite in Gaylord, you’re in for something comforting and full of character. Tucked along 314 S Otsego Ave, this spot leans into hearty German classics while still keeping things friendly and approachable. The menu feels like a warm invitation - think sizzling schnitzel, rich sausages, tangy sauerkraut, and potato dishes that actually taste homemade.
At the same time, it’s not all traditional plates. You’ll find stacked sandwiches, satisfying burgers, and shareable appetizers that pair perfectly with a cold beer. Everything reads like it was chosen to make you slow down and enjoy the moment, whether you’re stopping in for lunch or settling in for a relaxed dinner. The portions are generous, the flavors are bold without being overwhelming, and there’s a cozy, small-town charm behind every item listed.